Good topic.
This is a fresh and new discussion. I do not think anyone has brought up this subject before.

Well if I was going to live in the lighthouse, it would have to roomy. I am surprised nobody has said these yet, especially Rich.

My favorite lighthouse replicate to live in (with my wife in mind) would be
St Augustine
Then St Simons.
And I would live in them right where they are.

My third choice, because of the Kid in me, is Navesink. I love that castle look.