Lets just ASSUME for a bit that the Chops are indeed the rumored collector's society pieces, then which light do YOU think will be the membership piece (free w/ membership) and which light will be the exclusive redemption piece?

I think it will be as follows:

East Chop Light (Just Tower) -Free Gift with Membership
West Chop Light (Tower w/ Keepers House) -Redemption Piece

What do you think? ....of course this is just "fun speculation", nothing official.... I'm sure someday we will see these light be made! (food for thought!)