Just looked at an excellent illustration of the old St. Simons light in Kevin McCarthy's "Georgia Lighthouses & Historic Coastal Sites". It does bear a strong resemblance to Sandy Hook and a few other of the late 1700/early 1800 octagonal lighthouses. Shorter than the current tower, old St. Simons was 75 ft tall and, in 1857, was equipped with a 3rd order, double convex Fresnel lens. I agree that Old St. Simons would be an excellent addition to the HL line and a great companion piece to the "new" St. Simons.