Sandy-

You have a lot of lights in there I've never heard of! Most of them seem to be on inland lakes. Some are also ruins, etc. We are going to have to put a limit on those kinds of "lights", or else we'll be stuck on New York forever.

I Googled each of these lights.

Here's my findings on the lights:

Blackwell Island Light - Have it...same as Roosevelt Island. Please correct me if I'm wrong.
Cayuga Inlet Light On an inland lake. This is pushing it.
Cayuga Inlet Breakwater Same as above.
Gardiners Island (ruins) Seems to be just ruins, if there's anything left at all. I'll ask my dad if there is anything left (this is around where he goes sailing), but I think this is out.
Great Beds Light Definitely NJ. It's on my NJ poster, it's in an NJ river...no dispute on this one.
King's Point Light Nothing came up on a Google...this one's out.
Lido Beach Light Nothing came up on a Google except for a navigational aids list and a porn site.
Rondout Creek I (foundation only) If there's just a foundation, it's out.
Shinnecock Light If someone's seen it, this can count, but as it was torn down in 1948, we'd be hard pressed to find someone.
Shoal Point Light Seems to be being restored, etc...on an inland lake. People seem to care about it...if someone's seen it, this can count.
Throg's Neck Just a square steel tower nowadays...this is really pushing it.
Whitestone Point Used to be really cool ( link ), but now just a skeleton...this is out.


Thanks for the list, though, Sandy! I just saw quite a bit of New York Googling these lights! We have to put a limit somehwhere, though.