Art, you apparently missed my answer of 4 on 10/6. I based my answer on a book I have titled "The Four Eddystone Lighthouses". Since you didn't respond to it, I thought maybe 4 was incorrect and did some research. I found the following link which has excerpts from another book which refers to the five lights including the reconstructed one.

http://www.cornwall-calling.co.uk/lighthouses/Eddystone.htm

Last but not least, the four lights builders were Winstanley, not Winstantson, Rudyerd, Smeaton and Douglass.

I'll post a question later today.

mg