Three of the ones listed by Paul are for rental only, no breakfast, unless there have been recent changes. The rentals only are Rose Island, Saugerties and Race Point.

Also, Isle au Haut was a B&B, but no longer as the keepers house was closed in 2008 and only a Woodshed Cottage is available for weekly rentals, but no breakfast provided. In addition the property was put up for sale in 2007, current asking price $2,200,000. Can we put a group together? LOL

http://www.keepershouse.com/

Last but not least, there are several books on lighthouse B&B's. If you don't want to buy a book,there is a website for lighthouses with overnight accomodations including B&B's for the U.S. as well as other countries. Note that many of the listings are for properties that are not real lighthouses. See below.

http://lighthouse.cc/links/overnight.html

I'm finished, Paul's turn.