Shipwrecked is one of the places I looked at for our dinner during the HL Mini-event. Sadly, they were too small for our group.
Canalover - Do you know if the ice cream place is open mid-May. I know Wilsons usually isn't open that early in the season. Wilsons are famous for their location and their ice cream sundaes.
I know a place in Door County that has fantastic hamburgers, but they only have about 8-10 tables. They can't serve too many people at once unless it is warm enough to sit at the tables outside.
Suzanne Murphy