LighthouseKeepers.com

Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons...

Posted By: Webmaster

Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/19/05 07:28 PM

I'm trying out some new indicators about whether there are new posts in forums since your last visit -- assuming you permit the CF to use cookies.

These would appear on the home page and on the 'home page' for each of the individual forums.





My thinking is that those bigger images we have been using take up quite a bit of cumulative vertical space. If you scroll, more screen to scroll; if you print it takes more paper.

What's your preference?

The text buttons or the lighthouse photos?
Posted By: ericlighthouse

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/19/05 07:52 PM

Text sounds like a good idea to me.
Posted By: beachcomber

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/19/05 08:30 PM

The buttons sound better to me, too, John.
Posted By: flacoastie

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/19/05 08:39 PM

I like the text better also. It just stands there and screams right out at you "Hey I'm New".
Posted By: seagirt

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/19/05 08:39 PM

I preferred the icons. They tie in better designwise. Maybe if they were smaller, like 50x50?

These seem really confusing to me, though...hard to diffrentiate.
Posted By: beachcomber

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/19/05 08:42 PM

I tried scrolling up and down and it's a lot quicker to find stuff. I agree with Rich that it's easier to spot what's new, too. The pictures, although nice, take up too much space.
Posted By: Lighthouse Duo

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/19/05 09:50 PM

Sorry, I am with Greg! I prefer the pictures. But maybe they could be smaller?
smile
Posted By: Lighthouse Ghost

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/19/05 10:17 PM

I too prefer the icons/photos.

Lighthouse Ghost
Posted By: fra02441

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/19/05 11:20 PM

I also liked the icons.
Posted By: rscroope

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/19/05 11:46 PM

They got my attention John which is`what I think your trying For!
Bob
Posted By: Webmaster

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/20/05 04:33 AM

5-4 for the 'text' buttons...

...but are these a good compromise:



Posted By: Lighthouse Ghost

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/20/05 04:45 AM

That is not bad John, but put the lighthouse in both pictures. You could switch the text to "YES" and "NO" and that way have the best of both worlds!

Lighthouse Ghost
Posted By: seagirt

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/20/05 05:07 AM

These are MUCH better...only suggestion...keep the general image the same as before, but different size. I think that people are used to the old images for old and new posts, and it'll be easier to adjust.

BTW, like the new buttons on the bottom for posting and replying, too! smile
Posted By: flacoastie

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/20/05 05:19 AM

Keep the lighthouse in both pictures and just show a Red "YES" in the new topics. If the word "NO" appears in old topics it will be too cluttered. The "YES" really stands out great. It is the "pictures tell a thousand words" theme that you have going here. I also like the "post" topic pictures. It is also easy to pick out.
Posted By: Dave H

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/20/05 05:56 AM

The thin pictures seem to be a good compromise. I like the word "new" instead of "yes" - think it makes more sense. I would agree with Scott about leaving the light in both pictures. With the word "new" literally blaring at you it will be very hard to miss the obvious.
Posted By: Lighthouse Ghost

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/20/05 06:05 AM

The more I think about it, flacoastie is right in that having the "YES" and "NO" might make it too cluttered. In that case, I am with Dave in that "NEW" is better, I simply suggested "YES" and "NO" because they go together and I think "NOPE" would cover the lighthouse if you put it back in the picture.

Just my 2 cents.

Lighthouse Ghost
Posted By: beachcomber

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/20/05 09:28 AM

Lighthouse in both; "new" only.
Posted By: fra02441

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/20/05 03:44 PM

Agree with Grace. Just new is enough
Posted By: fra02441

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/20/05 03:46 PM

We need a lighthouse in old it looks naked
Posted By: Webmaster

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/20/05 04:13 PM

Well that was pretty unanimous in the 'overnight vote' so...

...you got it.
Posted By: ericlighthouse

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/20/05 04:23 PM

Looks Good.
Posted By: Lighthouse Duo

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/20/05 04:26 PM

... like it !!! smile
Posted By: WackoPaul

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/20/05 04:56 PM

I use today's active topics to navigate the forums and read what has been recently posted.. That way I don't just see the latest thread that has been repsonded to in a forum..
Posted By: Webmaster

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/20/05 05:04 PM

Me, too, Paul... In fact, it's my HOME PAGE.

For those unfamiliar with this view:

http://www.lighthousekeepers.com/cgi-bin/forumscgi/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_daily
Posted By: Lighthouser

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/20/05 06:14 PM

John, my preference is the lighthouse photos. I find those labels distracting and kinda loud-they shout out at you.

Now if you could make the lighthouse photo light up when there are new posts, that would be kinda cool.

Anyway, like Paul, I almost always go to the "Today's Topic's" page. Only if I've been away for awhile do I search the other page which I guess is really the "home" page.

Judy
Posted By: PFC

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/20/05 07:43 PM

Hi All, Count me as #4, I also go to "Todays Active Topics" when I check in!

I also agree with Judy
Quote:
John, my preference is the lighthouse photos. I find those labels distracting and kinda loud-they shout out at you. eek
My best, :rolleyes:
Paul Conlin
Posted By: beachcomber

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/20/05 11:02 PM

I go to "Today's Active Topics", as well, but like the new view when I go to the homepage. Scrolling is a lot quicker.
Posted By: Dave H

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/20/05 11:20 PM

Is it possible the text size on the main page also shrank, or do the new skinnier pictures give that impression?
Posted By: rgurskey

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/21/05 12:34 AM

Quote:
I find those labels distracting and kinda loud-they shout out at you.
I quite agree. I prefer the two icons.
Posted By: Webmaster

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/21/05 12:37 AM

Quote:
Originally posted by Dave H:
Is it possible the text size on the main page also shrank, or do the new skinnier pictures give that impression?
Optical illusion - or your eyes are going bad.

Well, I think it's going to be the way it is now for a while anyway.

Quote:
"You can please some of the people some of the time, but you can't please all of the people all of the time." -- Abraham Lincoln
Posted By: flacoastie

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/21/05 01:51 AM

Well, as the saying goes "I'm pleased as punch". Thanks John!
Posted By: bright eyes

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/21/05 03:13 PM

smile A first class look!!! wink
Posted By: MtnHkr

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/21/05 04:09 PM

Never saw it looking better! Thanks John for the changes every once in a while.
Posted By: sandy

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/21/05 06:21 PM

Gees! Go away for a week and everything's changed!! Like the new look. As to where I go when I enter the site--just like the newspaper, read it front to back. First "new" becomes first read.

Had perfect weather in GA and SC all of last week. Lots of pics to post when photographer and I choose which to keep and then clean them up.
Posted By: beachcomber

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/21/05 11:15 PM

I'm like you, Sandy. I have to see the whole thing. John, I frequently refer to old posts so it's a lot easier the new way. Thanks for coming up with such great ideas! Are you still thinking of changing the banner at the top?
Posted By: Lighthouse Duo

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/22/05 12:19 AM

I am with Sandy... first NEW is first read top tp bottom ... From the home page not the active topics page...
I like the new look. It does make it easier to see the forums listed like this...
Posted By: fra02441

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/22/05 01:58 AM

Perfect smile
Posted By: seagirt

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/22/05 02:04 AM

I've definitely adjusted now, and love these even more than the big icons. My only idea is to make the icons for new/no new posts from the same section of the image as the old ones. Maybe some continuity would help us all with recognition. I personally like the contrasting colours when zipping through the page with a few spins of the scrollwheel - they pop out more than the same image with text.

But it's still really good this way...

BTW, yes...I'm an index pager. Never really liked the Active Topics page...more fun to see it from the actual forum page.
Posted By: Dave H

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/22/05 03:39 AM

Greg, when the word "new" blares out from the screen, it will be pretty obvious to all that there is something different in those threads, perhaps something new?
Posted By: sandy

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/22/05 08:24 PM

Greg,

You're much too young to be having senior moments! laugh laugh laugh

Sandy
Posted By: rscroope

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/22/05 09:02 PM

That's right Sandy! Greg's only 16, and won't be a Senior until a least next year!
Posted By: Webmaster

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/23/05 06:39 PM

Greg's a Sophmore this year. Unless they jump him a year, he'll be a Junior next Fall.
Posted By: seagirt

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/23/05 07:53 PM

Trust me, I might be smart, but I don't think I'll be skipping any grades anytime soon. smile
Posted By: rscroope

Re: Trying out some "new" and "nope" buttons... - 11/23/05 09:01 PM

Quote:
Originally posted by seagirt:
Trust me, I might be smart, but I don't think I'll be skipping any grades anytime soon. smile
That could be the most profound statement you've made on the Forum, Greg? :p
Bob
© 2024 Collector Forums