Joe and I have been down to the Keys on several occasions on Scuba Diving Trips. We normally spend a week down there when we go, though we haven't been there in several years. We like to stay in Marathon (the half way point) that way we can go north east to Key Largo one day and south west to Key West the next, then back again if we want.
The Motel that we stay in at Marathon is the Sea Cove. Its a small place on the left just as you come into town. Small cottages with full Kitchenettes complete with dishes, 2 double beds and lots of room. This is nothing fancy, but clean and very reasonably priced. Now remember that it has been several years, but the room rates were $24. a night and they gave us a discount for renting by the week and we paid $140. Again let me say that this was nothing fancy, not a resort, but we stayed a whole week for the price that you would pay for one night at those fancy places.
Sea Cove (mile marker 54) 1-800-653-0800 or 305-289-0800Then there is a place that we have stayed in twice down in Key West the Spanish Gardens Motel. Again nothing fancy, but clean and priced right. This motel is only 2 blocks for the Southernmost Point and within walking distance to the Lighthouse and Malloey Square. I think we paid something like $45. a night there. Again a great bargain compared to the fancy resort hotels.
Spanish Gardens Motel 1325 Simonton St. Key West 305-294-1051I hope this information will be of some help to you!
Good Luck and Have Fun! Wish I was going too!
Stephanie