If redoing a small number of historically significant lights shown at an important point in their history were to be considered by HL, I think these pieces should be issued only one each year as Society pieces during a brief order window like Rose Island. They would be for targeted to committed HL collectors and resulting edition sizes would likely be around 6,000 (like REXM). Every collector who wants one would have equal access and few would make their way to retail shelves.

Hopefully, HL would price them to recover production costs and normal profit.
I like John's idea of an optional special base or glass cover available for an additional tax-deductible cost to be applied to restoration or other good purposes.

These lights would become true collectibles in every sense of the word.