I saw MIB II also. I knew that there was a LH in Truro, but I knew that the one in the movie wasn't correct. I was barely in the door from the movie when I had my books out looking for the answer (which has been indicated above is Fire Island). Perhaps the Fire Island LH was more "picturesque" for their movie! Product placement, as well as background buildings and landmarks are very big business for movies. I sure hope that the Fire Island LH got a royalty for it's use!

chris g