I'm behind the Little Gull nomination. Having sailed past this light many times, it's got a place in my heart. Plus, it's quite cool - rough stones, interesting landscape, and it's just the tower, so it's the perfect size. And since it's a lesser-known light in the middle of LI Sound, it's probably not as likely to be made as a "mainstream" HL.

I can already envision it...the tall tower, the gulls (well, don't know if we can do gulls, but it would be a fun literal touch), the stormy whitecaps...a quintessential lighthouse visage.